Make a Payment Many carriers now allow you to check your payment balance and pay your insurance premium from a touch-tone telephone or online via their website.  You can normally access your last payment received, your unpaid balance as well as refunds and returned checks. Allied Insurance 800-282-1446 First American Specialty 888-474-7500 or click to pay online First Comp 888-500-3344 or click to pay online Foremost 800-527-4221 or click to pay online Infinity 800-782-1020 Mercury Insurance Group 888-637-2176 or click to pay online McGraw Group of Affiliated Companies 800-303-5000 Midwest Insurance 877-642-3729 Safeco Insurance 800-332-3226 Travelers 800-550-7716 or click to pay online Unitrin Specialty 888-834-7780 or click to pay online